Kate Butler’s A Chance To Be Happy is a novel with serious intentions—centered around trauma, healing, and self-identity. Told through the lens of a young woman processing grief, abuse, and mental illness, the story touches on powerful themes that deserve exploration. Unfortunately, its presentation often falters, leaving the emotional weight and character journey underdeveloped.
💔 What Didn’t Work for Me
Audience & Content Mismatch
While the book description notes “mild explicit content,” readers should be aware that the story includes references to suicide (including ideation and planning), substance abuse, physical and emotional domestic violence (largely off-screen), and verbal/emotional abuse from a parent. These are heavy themes that deserve stronger content or trigger warnings—especially given the age range listed (grades 10-12, ages 16-18).
Though categorized as New Adult, the author’s bio mentions writing for a young adult audience. The tone and style reflect that—simpler prose, limited emotional depth, and a voice that feels more YA than NA. This mismatch can be confusing for readers, especially when paired with subject matter that may not be appropriate for high school students without careful handling.
Narrative Structure & Style
The novel opens with a summary-heavy style that reads more like a personal essay or memoir than immersive fiction. There are tense inconsistencies, repetitive phrasing, and frequent sentence fragments. Internal thoughts are not clearly distinguished, and scene transitions often feel abrupt.
Several moments were jarring due to awkward word choices or disjointed shifts in tone. At least one or two lines appeared to be directly lifted from other media (notably Twilight), which further disrupted narrative trust. Minor punctuation errors (such as missing quotation marks) also pulled me out of the story.
Character Development & Agency
My biggest concern is the passivity of the protagonist. Rather than acting with agency, she mostly reacts to events happening around her—and even those reactions are muted. While I felt sympathy for her situation, I struggled to truly root for her. Her healing arc is vague, largely driven by other characters rather than internal growth.
There are also inconsistencies in her characterization (and others). A brother named Charlie is mentioned in the opening and closing chapters but is never explained. Her room changes color mid-book. Legal details about who helped her vary by chapter. These small things add up and chip away at believability.
Themes with Potential, But Missed Marks
I commend the author for tackling important themes—trauma, self-worth, mental health, and recovery. But these topics require careful emotional nuance, clarity, and careful pacing. In this case, the execution felt rushed and emotionally detached, limiting the reader’s ability to connect or process with care.
✍️ Final Thoughts
There’s this saying: “The tree remembers what the axe forgets.” It’s a beautiful, haunting line that encapsulates the emotional intention behind the novel. But ultimately, the narrative didn’t live up to that potential.
With stronger editing, a firmer grasp on audience expectations, and more emotional grounding in the protagonist’s journey, A Chance To Be Happy could become something powerful. As it stands, however, it left me unsettled—not because of the subject matter, but because of how it was handled.
Have you read A Chance To Be Happy?
Let’s talk about it.
Drop your thoughts below or head over to my socials to chat more bookish thoughts and theories. 💙
📖 Explore More in the Library